Analysis: Mike Shula wasn’t Plan A for Giants, but that might be OK

The New York Giants have employed Mike Shula as offensive coordinator, and the Big Blue Freakout is in full swing.

There are Giants followers able to bury Shula already, judging this as an terrible rent earlier than the person has even accomplished any work in New Jersey.


Here is among the response:

Shulas expertise is dangerous expertise
Mike Shula is the strolling speaking definition of nepotism this can be a dangerous rent!!!!

Never underestimate the ability of silly individuals in massive teams!

Posted by Late for Dinner

This is certainly the “we missed out on our two options” of hires

Posted by Joshua Ryan

Bahahahaha
and the dumpster hearth retains burning…this #2 choose higher be epic…that’s all we now have to sit up for.

Posted by JamieKage

Even Panthers followers are sympathetic.


Is it actually that dangerous?

Step again from the ledge and keep in mind — this may NOT be Mike Shula’s offense. He is not going to be designing the majority of it, putting in or creating the scheme, or calling the performs. Head coach Pat Shurmur will be doing that.

Shula will be working with quarterbacks, which he has huge expertise doing. He will be the accountable for ensuring gamers run the offense the way in which Shurmur needs it run. As a veteran play-caller he can be a sounding board for Shurmur. As a coordinator, Shula’s play-calling was criticized but not his skill to seek out artistic wrinkles so as to add to the playbook. Perhaps he may help Shurmur discover a number of of these every week.

I requested Bradley Smith of SB Nation’s Panthers’ web site, Cat Scratch Reader, for his ideas on Shula. Here is what he despatched me, through e-mail:

Aside from the 2015 season, Mike Shula’s time in Carolina was marred with disappointment. One of the largest issues we had with him was he couldn’t regulate to what the opposite workforce was doing in the course of the recreation. He is also horrible at situational play-calling and may get predictable at instances. Panthers followers as an entire just about hate him at this level as a result of his lack of play-calling skill hindered the offense a lot. To be honest to him, each fan base hates their offensive coordinator and he acquired loads of hate that he actually didn’t deserve. Even when his play-calls have been good, but didn’t work due to dangerous execution by the gamers, he nonetheless took the blame.

Basically, if the Giants are hiring him to name performs it’s a horrible thought. If they’re hiring him to seek the advice of with the play-caller and craft the offense, then it’s an excellent rent. Shula is artistic, and he could make an offense work across the personnel he’s given… so long as you don’t let him handle the situational play calling duties.

My movie guys like his offensive scheme. You can look by means of our movie room part on our website and presumably glean some content material from there – https://www.catscratchreader.com/carolina-panthers-film-room

Here are a few tweets from these Cat Scratch Reader movie guys:

Here is how Shula’s offenses in Carolina stacked up statistically:


gif;base64,R0lGODlhAQABAIAAAAUEBAAAACwAAAAAAQABAAACAkQBADs - Analysis: Mike Shula wasn’t Plan A for Giants, but that might be OK

The dashing offenses have, statistically, been glorious. A massive chunk of that, although, got here from quarterback Cam Newton. In Shula’s 5 years in Carolina, Newton ran for lower than 500 yards solely as soon as. So, with no cell quarterback can Shula add a lot to the run ideas that will be in Shurmur’s offense? We will see.

Our personal Dan Pizzuta has expressed blended emotions in regards to the rent, but on the optimistic facet he additionally expressed some optimism about Shula’s skill to construct artistic wrinkles into an offense.

It is clear that Shula was not the Giants’ first alternative for the job. Shurmur needed Kevin Stefanski, with whom he labored in Minnesota. That, although, didn’t occur. There is a few indication that the Giants might have made a late push for Nick Sirianni, the previous Los Angeles Chargers vast receivers coach who will grow to be offensive coordinator of the Indianapolis Colts.

Shula isn’t a younger, up-and-coming, untested coach like Stefanski or Sirianni. He is 52 and has been teaching since 1988, 30 years in the past. He has warts. His tenure as Alabama head coach (2003-2006) didn’t go properly. He has been an offensive coordinator within the NFL twice earlier than, calling performs and designing offenses for 9 years. There has been some good and a few dangerous within the work that he’s accomplished.

I mentioned it earlier than but you will need to keep in mind that this may be Shurmur’s offense, not Shula’s. If Shula’s expertise and popularity for creativity can add a number of issues to it, that will be an excellent factor.

Let it play out, Giants followers. Hiring Shula might not have been Plan A, but it might find yourself simply advantageous.

You might also like More from author

Leave A Reply

Your email address will not be published.